Understanding Weight Loss Surgery
We have already reviewed many principals for correcting the root causes of
obesity, but do these strategies work when you are sixty, eighty, or a hun-
dred pounds overweight? How about two hundred, three hundred pounds,
or more? Is it enough to simply change your nutrition and add regular
activity to your routine? Often, these tools are inadequate by themselves
to produce the changes necessary for expected and sustainable results, and
additional tools become necessary.
To drive this point home, I often use an analogy. A builder shows up
on a job site to build kitchen cabinets. As he prepares to work, he opens
his toolbox and finds that the only tool available is a hammer. How suc-
cessful will this builder be in completing the task at hand if his only tool
is a hammer? The answer is obvious. Not very successful. Similarly, if that
same builder shows up to a job site to build the same cabinets, opens his
toolbox, and finds a variety of tools available, but the hammer is missing, he
will still have difficulty completing the project because a hammer does not
substitute for a saw, and a saw does not substitute for a hammer. You need
the appropriate complement of tools to accomplish the task in front of you.
Health and wellness and the journey toward successful weight loss
work in exactly the same way. If you are trying to lose weight by throwing
a hammer at the job, you will never be successful long-term. Most people
fail to recognize the comprehensive nature necessary to achieve ultimate
health and wellness, which leads to sustainable weight loss. Over and over
again, they try to achieve that desired weight loss by employing a singular
technique (e.g., dietary change, exercise, weight-loss medications). It simply
does not work. But the deeper question is, why?
Revisiting the Set-Point Theory
When your body exists in a state of equilibrium, your calorie intake matches
your metabolism and energy expenditure necessary to maintain a constant
weight. One day you decide you want to lose weight, and you initiate a
significant calorie reduction. Maybe you currently eat 2000 calories a day
and have now moved to a 1200-calories-a-day diet. How does the body
Respond?
Our physiology has amazing autoregulatory mechanisms that recognize
you have now moved your caloric intake to a point where it no longer meets
the demands required to maintain this level of equilibrium. So, it adjusts.
The first way it adjusts is by decreasing your metabolism. It also begins a
prioritization process, identifying those systems more critical to your body’s survival and those less important.
The heart and brain are considered the
body’s number one priorities. On the flip side, your hair, nails, and skin are
among the lowest priorities. This is one of the primary reasons hair loss
develops after a prolonged calorie deficit. As your metabolism continues
to decrease to match its new caloric intake, the initial weight loss slows
to a halt and then begins to return to its previous weight. And the cycle
begins again. Defeated, patients will often return to old habits or look to
implement yet another program.
Since the 1950s, physicians have insisted that an “eat less, do more”
approach is all that is necessary to achieve desired weight loss. I was one of
those physicians. For years, I patronized patients by telling them, “Weight
loss is easy; just balance the equation!” How incredibly insulting. As I write
those words, I am embarrassed at the complete naivety of that statement.
I didn’t intend to be insulting. Those words were spoken out of a lack of
modern education. In fact, I continue to remain amazed that nutrition has
never become a focus for medical student education. It is a subject that
is glossed over in most medical schools, and the limited education that
is provided continues to center around this flawed calories-based theory.
Once we recognized the inherent flaw of the calories-based philosophy
of weight loss, a comprehensive, more accurate philosophy emerged based
on the complexities of our physiology.
This philosophy, known as the set-point theory, essentially describes a genetically
imprinted set point in the brain, specifically the hypothalamus, controlled by a complex interplay
of these various hormones. This set point controls the weight your body
wants to maintain and is regulated by these circulating hormones. It’s
kind of like your body’s thermostat. In a room, the thermostat regulates
the temperature by either cycling in cold or hot air to maintain the desired
set point. Our bodies accomplish something similar by regulating various
physiologic parameters responding to these hormones, ultimately leading
to the restoration of their original body weight.
One may diet, count calories, exercise, or take diet pills and enjoy
early weight-loss success, but many will struggle to attain their target goal
weight, and most will never be able to maintain that initial weight loss.
Why? Because they have artificially forced their weight below the body’s
set point and are fighting against those autoregulatory mechanisms that
tend to pull them back to their initial weight. The obvious question is,
therefore, can you change this set point? The answer is a resounding YES!
Bariatric surgeries are procedures performed on the stomach or intes-
tines to induce weight loss and are one of the most powerful and durable
ways of changing this set point. This is a crucial point to understand and
requires clarification. In fact, this concept is in direct contrast to what
many have believed for decades. Because most patients, and for that matter
many physicians, are still caught up in the calories-in/calories-out model,
surgery simply becomes a means of forcing a patient to reduce their caloric
intake and, in a sense, accommodating one’s inadequacies or inability to
stop eating. This serious misconception has some profound consequences.
Internal data from our practice demonstrates that patients wait an
average of eighteen months from the time they first consider weight-loss
surgery until they step foot in our office for a face-to-face consult. We
have often wondered what is occurring during these eighteen months. Are
they trying one last diet push? Is life just getting in the way of making it
a priority? Are they being told they can do it on their own and don’t need
something as extreme as surgery? The reality is that many things are often at
play, but a common theme seems to be patients wrestling with the internal
conflict of feeling like they should be able to do this on their own—that
surgery is the easy way out, that it’s cheating. When you’ve bought into the
philosophy that weight loss is simply about balancing the energy formula
(calories in/calories out), it’s easy to understand why surgery is viewed as
cheating. In this light, surgery becomes a crutch simply forcing you to do
something you should be able to do on your own.
Debunking the Myth that Surgery Should be a Last Resort
Myth: Surgery is a last resort for people who keep failing to lose weight. It’s the
easy way out.
Truth: Surgery provides a physiologic mechanism that cannot be attained through
more effort, and it is one of the most powerful and durable ways of changing
this physiological set point.
When you buy into the idea that weight loss surgery is forcing you to do something you
should be able to do on your own, then surgery becomes the easy way out. It’s
cheating. It becomes something you must hide to escape the burden of guilt that
develops when you admit that surgery is necessary to overcome your inability
to put down the fork. Well-intentioned family and friends may say, “You don’t
need surgery; you can do this on your own.” But what are they really telling you?
They are essentially judging your prior efforts as inadequate and the sole reason
for your failure. “If you would simply try harder, you wouldn’t need surgery.” In
my estimation, this is one of the most detrimental statements that can be made
to a patient who has tried numerous attempts to lose weight and never found
success. Guilt compounds guilt until you begin to accept that you are a failure.
However, when you understand that surgery provides a physiologic mechanism
that cannot be attained through more effort, you begin to view surgery in a new
light. You see surgery as a unique tool that provides specific physiologic changes.
Once you realize that surgery is a unique tool capable of unlocking hormonal
and physiologic changes necessary and uniquely proficient at facilitating weight
loss, you might ask whether there are any reasons why one would consider
the surgical option. In fact, there has been recent recognition that surgery can
dramatically improve several obesity-related conditions, including diabetes,high blood pressure,
sleep apnea, and even symptoms of polycystic ovarian syndrome.
The American Medical Association has now recognized some bariatric procedures as a
treatment option for patients with type 2 diabetes, with rates as high as 95 percent!
The Problem with Purely Restrictive Weight Loss Surgery
Traditionally, weight-loss procedures have been partitioned into restrictive
and malabsorptive procedures. Restrictive procedures are those that force
you to consume less volume, thereby reducing your total caloric intake.
Malabsorptive procedures enhance weight loss by altering the structure of
the digestive tract, allowing food to bypass segments of the small intestine,
which decrease nutritional absorption. While these definitions are true,
they are far too simplistic. There is more significant complexity occurring
on a hormonal and cellular level.
It may come as some surprise, but surgery does not simply work by
forcing patients to decrease their calorie intake. This would take us right
back to the energy balance theory. The Metabolic Applied Research Strategy
(MARS) is a multi-year, multi-generational research program by Ethicon-
Endo Surgery to understand the physiologic and metabolic changes that
occur after bariatric surgery. Dr. Lee Kaplan, one of the principal investi-
gators of this program, noted that recent data from the MARS initiative
have “demonstrated that most of the effects of bariatric surgery result from
changes in neuroendocrine physiology caused by the surgical manipulations.
Although these operations have long been thought to work mechanically
(e.g., by physical restriction of food intake or blockage of nutrient absorp-
tion), we now know that most of the effects are physiological.”33 This study
has identified how hormones such as ghrelin, leptin, GLP1, insulin, and
many other molecules and physiologic pathways involved in metabolic
functions contribute to weight loss.
Appropriate and sustainable weight loss early and late post-op is
directly tied to modulating the hormone patterns responsible for the pre-
vious weight gain. Only when weight loss is realized through the proper
manipulation of these hormones will one find lasting changes associated
with an improved quality of life. Only then will you return to a life of
vitality and full of energy.
As one approaches surgery, it is vital to take inventory of those aspects
of life that may serve as a distraction. You must be willing to embrace a
comprehensive approach. You must be willing to critically and honestly
evaluate your habits, relationships, patterns, and philosophy about life and
be willing to change. We see it every day. People want the change without
being willing to change. They want results without having to put forth the
effort or give up what has resulted in their present condition.
In the next blog post, we will begin to unpack the four different bariatric
procedures currently offered in the United States today: gastric bypass,
Lap-Band, laparoscopic sleeve gastrectomy, and laparoscopic loop duodenal
switch. Our surgical practice is uniquely focused on foregut surgery, which
essentially encompasses weight loss and reflux surgery. As we have done
several thousands of these cases, we have a unique perspective on which
procedures are best utilized to help patients along their weight-loss journey.
Years of bariatric emergency room call at facilities designated as Centers of
Excellence certified by the American College of Surgeons Metabolic and
Bariatric Surgery Accreditation and Quality Improvement Program have
served to shape our current recommendations. As a result, we have a firm
grasp on the potential complications that can develop with each of the
bariatric procedures in use today. These complications will be sequentially
outlined as we describe each procedure in detail.
What you will not find described are some of the more recent, “min-
imally invasive” options like the intragastric balloon or the endoscopic
sleeve gastroplasty. Why? Very simply because they appear to violate the
principles outlined in detail throughout this book. These procedures are
merely designed to reduce the capacity of the stomach without modi-
fying hormonal patterns. This is known as a restrictive procedure. This
approach falls back on the calories-in/calories-out approach and doesn’t
work long-term. Unfortunately, this procedure is typically used as a quick
fix in patients who believe that it’s safer than surgery and want something
that isn’t permanent.
I would be remiss to dismiss this option without fairly admitting that
some patients may be good candidates for this procedure. Patients needing
to lose twenty to forty pounds who have thoroughly and honestly examined
their lives and concluded that poor nutrition, lack of exercise, and multiple
lifestyle issues have been responsible for their weight gain may consider this option.
If one needs a life reset and is committed to restructuring the
necessary components that will lead to sustainability over a six-month
period that the balloon is in place, then an intragastric balloon may be a
viable option. A few issues, however, must be considered. First, one must
recognize that their physiology will completely return to its pre-placement
state once the balloon is removed. What typically happens is that patients
soon regain most, if not all, their weight unless they have truly made major
adjustments to the health and wellness pillars previously discussed.
So, what about the endoscopic sleeve gastroplasty? This minimally
invasive weight loss procedure utilizes a specially designed suturing device
to place permanent stitches into the front and back wall of the stomach,
thereby creating a smaller functional stomach. Wait—another procedure
designed to make the stomach smaller? Yep! Once again, on the surface,
this sounds like a great option, as it accomplishes the same thing as a sleeve
gastrectomy but without the surgery. You must recognize, however, that
the stomach’s outside portion is left in place. It is not removed. Thus, the
procedure is only restrictive in nature. No hormonal changes occur.
How Weight Loss Surgery Works For You
Tools are implements used to modify raw materials for more perfect
purposes. They are considered extensions of one’s hand, and it is important
to remember that tools can accomplish nothing on their own. Similarly,
surgery has minimal capacity in and of itself to optimize one’s health and
wellness in a sustained and durable fashion. It is, therefore, imperative that
this tool is used for its intended purpose. Using any tool inappropriately
is a step in the wrong direction. Not only does the tool need to be used
appropriately, it needs to be used as part of a comprehensive approach
toward weight loss where other tools are also utilized. This goes back to our
builder analogy. You will never find weight-loss success by simply throwing
a hammer at the job. That is essentially what one does when they attempt
to allow surgery to do all the work for them. Surgery is not a cure!
The comprehensive approach toward weight loss has a precise struc-
tural outline. One of the strongest pieces of advice we can give anyone
considering weight-loss surgery is to ensure there is a very comprehensive
educational program associated with the weight-loss center. Our surgical program
includes a three-month educational curriculum called the Finish Strong© program.
This online curriculum was designed with the bariatric
patient in mind and for beginning the educational process of moving the
bariatric patient into the next phase of life. The first year after surgery is
not only when most of the expected weight loss will occur, but it is also
the period most critical for implementing the lifestyle changes necessary
to achieve sustainability.
We designed this program to aid the bariatric patient in building the
habits necessary for sustainability. These habits become the tools that fill
your personal toolbox with the resources necessary to make healthy choices
as you navigate the initial weight-loss journey and the life that emanates
from there. The Finish Strong© program is an interactive app that not only
challenges you with daily tasks but allows each patient to engage with
their personal health coach as they seek to personalize their progress. We
believe that a boutique approach to weight loss that includes the needed
education and the support to walk the journey alongside each patient
sets the Florida Coast Weight Loss Center apart. We are honored to see
patients from across the country; however, if you prefer a program closer
to home, look for one that offers the strategy outlined here.